I'm Staying with My Boys: The Heroic Life of Sgt. John Basilone, USMC by Jim ProserMy rating: 5 of 5 stars
As the author, I won't review this book but the comments about it. Overall, as is apparent in the 4.10 star rating, most people are happy with the book. However, there are those who object, rather strenuously, to my use of the first person in telling the story of a man I didn't know personally and a well-known hero at that.
A man who served with Sgt. Basilone and was a writer himself, Capt. Bill Lansford USMC, was very positive about my choice. Bill understood that dramatic license applies to any subject that a writer is brave enough to attempt, even one about a nationally recognized hero. Secondly, a younger Marine, Col. Ken Jordan was so enthusiastic that someone was at least writing the story of Sgt. Basilone that he encouraged me to write the introduction of the book and address this issue head-on. Thank you Col. Jordan. You will never know how close I was to giving up when you invited me for lunch that long-ago day in San Diego.
Thirdly, the Marine Corps Commandant that year of 2010, James T. Conway thought enough of the book to include it in his professional reading list for all Marines. It has remained there for many years. And finally, Sgt. Basilone's brother Carlo and sister Gladys approved of my manuscript with high praise. Apparently I came at least close to the mark.
For those who accuse me of a lack of respect, please reconsider. I admit that it was certainly outrageous that I, who never served in the military, would presume to speak in the voice of this timeless hero. However, it was not from a lack of respect and I hope you will reconsider your opinion in light of the above support the book has received.
The important thing is that my version of this Marine's story does at least shed some light on his life of selflessness, courage and commitment. My hope is that more, particularly young Marines, read the story of Sgt. Basilone and strive to emulate him.
View all my reviews
